Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort and Grapetree Bay Hotel & Villas? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which resort fits your next getaway.
Best for families, couples, and active travelers who want a historic St. Croix beach resort with golf, three private beaches, included breakfast, and a polished country-club feel.
Better for travelers who want a quieter east-end St. Croix stay with a simpler hotel-and-villa setup and a more low-key beach atmosphere.
If you want the more complete resort experience, The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort is the stronger pick: it has three private beaches, two outdoor pools, golf, a spa, multiple oceanfront restaurants, and kid-friendly programming without feeling like a kids-only property.
If your priority is a quieter, more understated St. Croix base with hotel-and-villa accommodations, Grapetree Bay Hotel & Villas is the better fit—especially if you prefer a relaxed setting over a larger resort campus.
Bottom line: choose The Buccaneer for the fuller historic resort experience with beaches, dining, golf, and family amenities; choose Grapetree Bay for a calmer, simpler St. Croix stay.
| Category | The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort | Grapetree Bay Hotel & Villas |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe | Historic, family-owned St. Croix resort with a country-club atmosphere, broad amenities, and a luxury-playground-for-all-ages feel. | Quiet hotel-and-villa style stay with a more relaxed, low-key beach-resort mood on St. Croix’s east end. |
| Location | Set northeast of Christiansted on a large tropical estate with direct access to three secluded private beaches. | Located around Grapetree Bay on St. Croix’s east end, better for travelers seeking a quieter setting away from the busier resort feel. |
| Rooms & Suites | 131 accommodations spread across a large historic resort property, with a polished but classic island-resort style. | Hotel rooms and villas suit travelers who want a simpler, more residential-feeling stay rather than a full-scale resort campus. |
| Dining | Three oceanfront or waterfront restaurants plus an open-air lounge, with included breakfast for most leisure stays and paid dining beyond breakfast. | More straightforward dining setup suited to guests who prefer a quieter property and may also explore St. Croix by car. |
| Pools & Beach | Three private beaches, complimentary non-motorized water gear at select beaches, and two freshwater outdoor pools. | A calmer bayfront beach setting that emphasizes relaxation more than a wide resort-beach circuit. |
| Kids & Family | All-ages resort with a complimentary daily Kid’s Camp for ages 4–12, family-friendly dining, beaches, pools, and resort activities. | Best for families or couples who want a quieter stay, though it does not match The Buccaneer’s breadth of documented kid-focused amenities. |
| Price & Value | Best value when you will use the beaches, pools, included breakfast, golf access, spa, fitness center, watersports gear, and family programming. | Best value for travelers who want a quieter hotel-and-villa experience and do not need the full amenity depth of a larger historic resort. |
Rooms and suites at The Buccaneer sit within a large historic resort estate, giving the stay a polished, classic St. Croix feel rather than a compact boutique-hotel experience.
The Buccaneer is the better pick if you want your room to be part of a full-service beach, golf, dining, and activity resort.
Grapetree Bay Hotel & Villas is better suited to travelers who prefer a quieter hotel-and-villa format, with a more relaxed residential feel than a large resort campus.
If you want a quieter base and a less built-out resort experience, Grapetree Bay Hotel & Villas may feel like the easier fit.
Dining at The Buccaneer is a clear advantage if you want several on-property options, from open-air fine dining in the Great House to casual beachfront meals steps from the sand.
Expect:
Grapetree Bay Hotel & Villas is a better match for travelers who are comfortable with a simpler dining rhythm and a quieter property atmosphere.
If on-property dining variety matters most, The Buccaneer is the stronger choice; if you prefer a quieter, less structured stay, Grapetree Bay keeps things simpler.
The Buccaneer’s beach setup is one of its biggest advantages: guests have access to three private beaches, plus two freshwater outdoor pools and complimentary non-motorized water gear at select beaches.
Grapetree Bay Hotel & Villas is better for travelers who want a quieter bayfront beach atmosphere rather than a resort with multiple private beach areas.
If beach variety, pools, and included watersports gear are priorities, The Buccaneer wins; if quiet by-the-bay relaxation matters more, Grapetree Bay is the softer choice.
The Buccaneer is an all-ages resort with documented children’s facilities, but it still appeals strongly to couples and adults thanks to its spacious layout and polished atmosphere.
Grapetree Bay Hotel & Villas can suit families who want a quieter St. Croix stay, but it is not the stronger option if dedicated kid programming is a top priority.
If children’s amenities are important, The Buccaneer is the safer choice; if your group wants a quieter hotel-and-villa setting, Grapetree Bay may be enough.
The Buccaneer delivers the most value when you will actually use the resort’s included and on-site amenities, especially the beaches, pools, breakfast, fitness center, watersports gear, and family programming.
Grapetree Bay Hotel & Villas is the better value if you want a quieter, simpler St. Croix base and do not need The Buccaneer’s broader resort infrastructure.
Choose The Buccaneer if you want the fuller resort experience: three private beaches, two pools, multiple restaurants, golf, spa options, included breakfast, and documented children’s programming.
Grapetree Bay is the better pick for travelers who want a quieter hotel-and-villa stay and a more low-key beach atmosphere on St. Croix’s east end.
For families, active couples, and guests who want a historic all-ages resort with more to do on property, The Buccaneer is the stronger overall choice.
If you want fewer moving parts, a calmer setting, and a simpler place to unwind, Grapetree Bay Hotel & Villas is the more relaxed alternative.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort:
