Estate Shoys, Christiansted, St. Croix, 824, VI
Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
dining
The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort Restaurants Ranked (Best Food, Best Ambience, Best Value)
Trying to decide where to eat at The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort? This in-depth guide ranks The Terrace, The Mermaid, Beauregard’s on the Beach, and the Martel Lounge by food quality, ambience, setting, and overall value—so you can plan the right meals for your stay. Whether you want open-air fine dining, casual beachfront seafood, sushi and tacos by the sand, or sunset drinks with harbor views, this breakdown shows which dining experiences are worth prioritizing.
Resort dining guide
Looking for the best restaurants at The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort? This guide ranks all five dining venues by what travelers actually care about: best food, best ambience, and best value—so you can plan your meals in St. Croix, US Virgin Islands, match the restaurant to your mood, and book the dinners that feel most "worth it" for your family-friendly Caribbean escape.
Quick takeaway:
At The Buccaneer, the "best" restaurant depends on the vibe you want: elevated oceanfront fine dining (The Mermaid), casual beachside Caribbean flair (Beauregard's on the Beach), elegant breakfast and multi-course dinners (The Terrace), or easy poolside drinks and light bites (The Mermaid Bar and Martel Lounge). Use the rankings below to decide quickly—then rotate your meals for variety across your stay.
At The Buccaneer, the "best" restaurant depends on the vibe you want: elevated oceanfront fine dining (The Mermaid), casual beachside Caribbean flair (Beauregard's on the Beach), elegant breakfast and multi-course dinners (The Terrace), or easy poolside drinks and light bites (The Mermaid Bar and Martel Lounge). Use the rankings below to decide quickly—then rotate your meals for variety across your stay.
Best fine dining: The Mermaid
Best beachside casual: Beauregard's
Best breakfast: The Terrace
Best for cocktails: Mermaid Bar
Jump to a section
Explore the resort
Continue planning your stay at The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort with these quick guides. Explore room categories and suite perks, browse restaurants and bars, preview golf and beach activities, and learn about the spa, weddings, and meeting spaces—so you can book the best family-friendly Caribbean experience in St. Croix, US Virgin Islands.
The Buccaneer Restaurants Ranked (Best Food, Best Ambience, Best Value)
This table is the fastest way to pick where to eat. "Best food" is the strongest overall flavor experience, "best ambience" is the most romantic or elevated feel, and "best value" is the easiest win when you want a solid meal without overthinking it.
| Category | Top pick | Runner-up | Why it wins |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best fine dining | The Mermaid | The Terrace | Most elevated oceanfront experience with creative Caribbean-inspired menus |
| Best casual dining | Beauregard's on the Beach | Martel Lounge | Relaxed beachside vibe with fresh seafood and island favorites |
| Best breakfast | The Terrace | N/A | Elegant indoor/outdoor setting with Caribbean breakfast classics and views |
| Best for cocktails | The Mermaid Bar | Martel Lounge | Sophisticated oceanfront bar perfect for sunset drinks and pre-dinner aperitifs |
| Best family-friendly | Beauregard's on the Beach | The Terrace | Casual atmosphere where kids feel welcome and menu has broad appeal |
Restaurant-by-Restaurant Guide
Below is a practical breakdown of each restaurant at The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort—what the vibe feels like, who it's best for, and how to fit it into your trip (romantic dinner, family meal, casual lunch, or sunset drinks before your evening plans).
The Terrace
The Terrace is the go-to choice for breakfast at The Buccaneer, offering an elegant indoor/outdoor setting with stunning Caribbean views. It's also open for dinner service with refined multi-course meals, making it ideal for special occasions and romantic evenings.
- Best for: breakfast, special-occasion dinners, couples, families who want a refined start to the day
- Vibe: elegant, relaxed, classic Caribbean resort
- Strategy: start your mornings here, then reserve one dinner for a multi-course celebration meal
Top strength: breakfast
Great for: couples + families
Best time: breakfast/dinner
The Mermaid
The Mermaid is The Buccaneer's signature fine-dining restaurant, offering oceanfront views and creative Caribbean-inspired menus. It's the top choice when you want the most elevated dining experience on property—perfect for anniversaries, proposals, and celebration dinners.
- Best for: couples, romantic dinners, special celebrations, foodies seeking the best meal
- Vibe: upscale, oceanfront, romantic
- Strategy: book The Mermaid for your "big night out" and pair it with sunset cocktails at the adjacent bar
Top strength: fine dining
Best for: romance
Perfect for: celebrations
The Mermaid Bar
The Mermaid Bar is the best spot for sunset cocktails at The Buccaneer, located adjacent to The Mermaid restaurant with stunning oceanfront views. It's ideal for pre-dinner drinks, romantic toasts, or simply unwinding after a day of golf or beach time.
- Best for: sunset cocktails, pre-dinner drinks, couples, adults looking for a sophisticated bar scene
- Vibe: sophisticated, oceanfront, relaxed elegance
- Strategy: arrive early for sunset, then transition to The Mermaid or The Terrace for dinner
Top strength: sunset views
Great for: cocktails
Best time: sunset/evening
Beauregard's on the Beach
Beauregard's on the Beach is the best casual beachside dining option at The Buccaneer, serving fresh seafood, island favorites, and classic Caribbean dishes. It's perfect for families, lunch after the beach, or a relaxed dinner when you want great food without the formality.
- Best for: families, casual lunches, beachside dinners, anyone who wants "feet in the sand" vibes
- Vibe: casual, beachfront, island-style relaxed
- Strategy: use Beauregard's for lunches and lighter dinners so you can stay close to the beach action
Top strength: beachside casual
Great for: families
Best time: lunch/dinner
Martel Lounge
Martel Lounge is the perfect poolside and beachfront bar for tropical cocktails, light bites, and all-day casual dining. It's your go-to spot when you want to stay near the beach or pool scene without a full sit-down meal.
- Best for: poolside drinks, light snacks, beach days, casual hangs with friends or family
- Vibe: laid-back, beachfront, tropical bar atmosphere
- Strategy: use Martel Lounge for midday refreshments and as a casual dinner backup when you want minimal fuss
Top strength: casual convenience
Best for: beach/pool days
Value pick
Smart Dining Tips (How to Plan Your Meals)
- Rotate your vibes: plan one fine-dining night (The Mermaid), one special breakfast or dinner (The Terrace), and fill in the rest with Beauregard's and Martel Lounge for casual meals.
- Book The Mermaid early: it's the most popular restaurant for couples and special occasions, so reserve in advance—especially during peak season.
- Use The Terrace for breakfast every day: it's the best way to start your mornings with views and quality food before hitting the beach or golf course.
- Keep lunch casual: Beauregard's on the Beach and Martel Lounge are your best bets when you want to stay close to the sand and water.
- Plan sunset cocktails at The Mermaid Bar: it's one of the best oceanfront views on property—arrive 30–45 minutes before sunset for the best experience.
Planning rule that works:
If you're staying 3–4 nights, do one dinner at The Mermaid, breakfast daily at The Terrace, and casual meals at Beauregard's or Martel. If you're staying 5+ nights, add a second special dinner at The Terrace and rotate beachside lunches.
If you're staying 3–4 nights, do one dinner at The Mermaid, breakfast daily at The Terrace, and casual meals at Beauregard's or Martel. If you're staying 5+ nights, add a second special dinner at The Terrace and rotate beachside lunches.
FAQ: The Buccaneer Restaurants
What are the best restaurants at The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort?
Most guests choose The Mermaid for the best fine dining and romantic ambience, The Terrace for the best breakfast and special-occasion dinners, and Beauregard's on the Beach for the best casual beachside meals. The Mermaid Bar is the top pick for sunset cocktails.
Which restaurant is best for couples?
The Mermaid is the top couples pick—it offers oceanfront fine dining, romantic ambience, and creative Caribbean-inspired menus. For a more relaxed but still elegant option, The Terrace also works well for couples, especially for multi-course dinners.
Which restaurants are best for families?
Beauregard's on the Beach is the most family-friendly option with a casual beachside vibe and broad menu appeal. The Terrace is also great for families, especially for breakfast when the atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming.
What's the best restaurant for breakfast?
The Terrace is the best (and primary) breakfast spot at The Buccaneer, offering elegant indoor/outdoor seating with Caribbean views and a menu featuring island breakfast classics and international favorites.
Do I need reservations at The Buccaneer restaurants?
Reservations are highly recommended for The Mermaid, especially during peak travel seasons and for sunset or celebration dinners. The Terrace also benefits from advance reservations for dinner service. Beauregard's and the bars typically don't require reservations.
Is there a dress code at The Buccaneer restaurants?
The Mermaid and The Terrace (dinner service) have a resort elegant dress code—think collared shirts for men, no swimwear, and nice casual attire. Beauregard's on the Beach and Martel Lounge are casual, and beachwear is acceptable during the day.
What's the best spot for sunset cocktails?
The Mermaid Bar is the best choice for sunset cocktails at The Buccaneer, offering oceanfront views and a sophisticated atmosphere. Arrive 30–45 minutes before sunset to secure the best seats and enjoy the full golden-hour experience.
BOOK YOUR STAY NOW
Questions? Contact Us!
- Agents Available 24/7
- Lowest Price Guaranteed
- Complimentary Perks & Upgrades
- Agents Available 24/7
- Lowest Price Guaranteed​
- Complimentary Perks & Upgrades​
More The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort Guides
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort:
- Best Rooms at The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort (Top Suites Ranked by View, Value & Perks)
- Is The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort Good for Weddings? (Packages, Venues, Costs & Real Pros/Cons)
- Best Time to Visit The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort (Month-by-Month)
- The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort Nightlife Guide: Parties, Shows, Bars & What to Expect
- The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort: Month-by-Month Weather Guide
- How Many Nights Should You Stay at The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort?
- Is The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort Worth It? Honest Review (Pros, Cons & Who It's Best For)
- What to Pack for The Buccaneer Beach & Golf Resort: The Ultimate All-Inclusive Packing List